Okay hear me out:

You know how random the giving tree is right? And how it's a great feature.

BUT! What if there was a slight change?
I had a dream (this was in a dream, weird) where there are two 'sides'
If your lion is good, you get to go to the angelic side of the tree, where you can get good cubbies.
But the twist is: they were once old lion/lionesses.
Yes, what if old lions that passed on get reincarnated as cubs again and are able to be adopted?
You go there to get your cubs like the normal tree, but you'll most likely get pretty cubs and higher stat cubs, the higher your karma, the better your chance to get rare cubs. (mottled rosettes, and in rarer chances, mutations)

If your karma is neither good nor bad, you get the normal giving tree, nothing special.

But if you're an evil lion, you get the devil lion. Where you get cubs that you and other players have KILLED. Yes, killed. And you know that the potatoes are the ones that are usually killed, so you know what that means, YOU get the potatoes. You *may* get lucky and get good cubs, but this is the devil's way of 'punishing' you for your awful deeds.

Well? What do you think? Want to add/get rid of anything? Let me know!

*EDIT*: Okay thanks to some friends (Mal and Rowan) I'm gonna fix this up.
Evil lions won't just get potato cubs, but it'll be a little harder to get the better cubs, but it won't always be bad cubs.
Neutral will also get the equal chance to get the cubs as well.
And there's an evil counterpart to the angel lion, like a fallen angel one. Where you can get either good OR bad cubs, regardless of your karma. But choose wisely, as you only can take one per day from either lions.

K ANOTHER EDIT: Since people find this unfair (while I didn't want it to seem like I wanted to punish people for evil lions)
Good/kind lions OR lions who were part of a good pride, they go to the good side.
Evil/snarky lions or lions who were part of a bad pride, go to the bad side.
(this was suggested by multiple people)