It's almost time to retire my old king and I've narrowed it down to two possible replacements and I'd like your help deciding which to crown as my next heir. I'm not really that worried about the stats, but rather which do you think is prettier and would be more popular to stud out?

Keep in mind that King #2 is a mutation (blind).

Any suggestions or criticisms (as long as they are constructive) are welcome.


King #1
King #2